Jameis Winston vs. Geno Smith: Who Should You Start in Week 5?

Start Jameis Winston. Winston is projected for 13.6 PPR points vs 13.3 for Geno Smith, and faces the 3rd-softest defense against QBs this week.

Updated Oct 10, 11:50 PM ET

Jameis Winston vs. Geno Smith: Week 5 side by side

Jameis Winston
QB · NYG
Geno Smith
QB · NYJ
Projection (Week 5, avg of sources)13.613.3
Floor (lowest source)10.510.6
Ceiling (highest source)15.714.7
StatChasers projection15.7 (QB19)14.2 (QB27)
Opponentvs WASvs CLE
Opponent vs. position3rd-softest (23.3 pts/g allowed)9th-softest (19.4 pts/g allowed)
Recent usage1% target share (last 6)—
PositionQBQB
Our callSIT · BenchSIT · Bench

Settle every start/sit call with projections, matchup, recent usage and floor-versus-ceiling for your exact scoring settings.

Other comparisons

Other Jameis Winston comparisons

Other Geno Smith comparisons