Theo Johnson headshot

Theo Johnson 2026 Fantasy Outlook

#84 Tight End

25 yrs 6'6", 264 lbs Penn State 3rd Season 2024 R4, P107

Giants#84TEActive

25 yrs6'6"264 lbs

Penn State

View fantasy profile

Fantasy · PPR

2026 Fantasy Season

2.5FPPG · PPRTE57POS RANK2%ROSTERED

2026 Regular Season

  • 63REC YDS
  • 5REC
  • 1REC TD
  • 12.6YPR
Next matchupWeek 11 vs. Jacksonville JaguarsSun Nov 22, 4:25 PM ET24th vs. TEs, toughView matchup

Theo Johnson Rest-of-Season Projection

TE2 on the depth chartQB changeTough upcoming schedule

TE2 on the depth chart, production in line with expectation.

  • Johnson's 4.1% target share leads his role. His 3.5 PPR points a game sit right at the 4.4 expected, so this is volume, not a hot streak.

  • J.J. McCarthy is now the Giants' listed starting quarterback; Jameis Winston threw most of the passes through Week 10, and McCarthy has 104 attempts so far. That introduces uncertainty around how the targets are distributed. Two of his next four opponents are among the stingiest defenses against TEs: the Jaguars in Week 11 (24th) and the Seahawks in Week 14 (25th). He is TE2 on the depth chart, so his value depends on the players ahead of him, and a new quarterback and difficult upcoming matchups make even that less predictable.

What supports his value

His season-to-date usage was a starter's, but the depth chart no longer lists him first.

What threatens his value

Two difficult matchups in his next four, uncertainty over how targets are distributed with McCarthy starting and a TE2 spot on the depth chart.

Opportunity vs. Production

Through Week 10, PPR. Expected points (xFP) is the fantasy value of the opportunities he is given; points over expected (FPOE) is what he has scored above or below that. Ranks are among qualifying TEs league-wide.

Production Efficiency
PPR points per game
3.5
Actual
Expected points per game
4.4
xFP
Points over expected
−0.9
per game
Opportunity Share
Target share
4.1%
First-read share
4.6%
Snap share
25%

Production is running about at expectation.Johnson's production is running right at expected (3.5 scored against 4.4 expected), so this is volume, not a hot streak.

Recent target share is steady.His target share is steady: 4.4% over his last three games against 4.8% in Weeks 2-4.

Snap share has risen.His snap share is up 5 points over the same window (23% of snaps).

See the Giants usage report

What Drives Theo Johnson's Fantasy Value?

His 2026 rank through Week 10 among the tight ends who have played at least six games. Each row names its field. Each bar is one tight end, best on the left; his is highlighted.

Target share

4.1%target share

Fewer than 6 games in 2026, so not ranked.

Expected points

4.4xFP per game

Fewer than 6 games in 2026, so not ranked.

Points over expected

Near expected
−0.9FPOE per game

Fewer than 6 games in 2026, so not ranked.

First-read share

4.6%first-read share

Fewer than 6 games in 2026, so not ranked.

Average depth of target
10.1
Drop rate
0.0%
Red-zone targets
1
YAC per reception
4.0

What Could Change His Value

Risk

  • A new quarterbackJ.J. McCarthy is now the listed starter; Jameis Winston threw most of the passes through Week 10. How targets are distributed under McCarthy is unknown (104 attempts so far).
  • Tough matchupsThe Jaguars in Week 11 (24th) and the Seahawks in Week 14 (25th) are among the stingiest defenses against TEs.
  • RoleHe's TE2 on the depth chart, so a bigger role needs a change ahead of him.
Weighing Johnson against another tight end on your roster?Compare them in Redraft Command

Theo Johnson Upcoming Matchups

His next four opponents, ranked by PPR points allowed to TEs this season: 1st allows the most, 32nd the fewest.

  • Wk 11vs JAX24th vs TEsToughJacksonville Jaguars logo
  • Wk 12at IND14th vs TEsNeutralIndianapolis Colts logo
  • Wk 13vs SF16th vs TEsNeutralSan Francisco 49ers logo
  • Wk 14at SEA25th vs TEsToughSeattle Seahawks logo

A difficult stretch: two of the next four are bottom-10 matchups for TEs.

Fantasy playoffs (Weeks 15 to 17): vs Browns in Week 15 (12th), at Lions in Week 16 (1st) and at Cowboys in Week 17 (17th); one favorable, none tough.

Read our preseason outlook (June 2026)

Published June 17, 2026. Kept for reference; the outlook above replaces it. Point totals in this piece are as published in June; the figures above are PPR points per game.

Johnson took a clear step forward in 2025, ranking TE19 with 82.8 fantasy points across 15 games on an 86.7 percent snap share. The 2024 fourth-rounder (Pick 107, Penn State) more than doubled his target share to 14.7 percent from 7.8 and lifted yards per route run to 1.18 from 0.84, hauling in 45 of 74 targets for 528 yards and five scores. The biggest leap was usage near the goal line: 14 red-zone and six end-zone targets, up from one each in 2024, the engine behind his touchdown production.

The concerns are catch quality, a 60.8 percent catch rate, five drops and a 6.8 drop rate, plus a modest 0.119 EPA per play that caps his ceiling. Still, as a near-every-down option in a thin Giants pass-catching corps, his volume and red-zone role give him a stable streaming floor with TE1 spike weeks. For 2026 he is a low-end starter and strong dynasty hold, draftable as a back-end TE1 with room to grow.

Keep researching Theo Johnson

Theo Johnson Fantasy Outlook FAQ

What is Theo Johnson's fantasy outlook for the rest of the 2026 season?

Theo Johnson projects as a depth TE for deep leagues only for the rest of the 2026 season: a bench stash in TE-premium leagues and waiver-wire material in 12-team and 10-team leagues. His 3.5 PPR points a game match his 4.4 expected, so the production is the role. J.J. McCarthy taking over at quarterback makes the near term less predictable. See his live rank in Redraft Command.

What is Theo Johnson's rest-of-season fantasy ranking?

Theo Johnson is the TE57 in PPR points per game through Week 10. That puts him in depth TE territory, waiver-wire material in 12-team leagues.

Should I buy low or sell high on Theo Johnson?

Neither: Theo Johnson's 3.5 PPR points a game sit close to his 4.4 expected, so his price matches his role. Hold him unless a trade fills a bigger need.

Who is Theo Johnson's quarterback?

J.J. McCarthy is the Giants' listed starting quarterback now. Jameis Winston threw most of the passes through Week 10; McCarthy has 104 attempts so far. How the targets are distributed under the new starter is the open question for Johnson's rest-of-season value.

What is Theo Johnson's projected role going forward?

Theo Johnson is TE2 on the depth chart, so a bigger role needs an injury or a change ahead of him.

Will Theo Johnson get more targets?

Theo Johnson's targets are holding steady: 1.5 a game over his last two games against 1.7 for the season. With J.J. McCarthy now starting, the next two games will say more than the last two.

What is Theo Johnson's fantasy football upside?

Theo Johnson's upside: his ceiling this season is 8.1 PPR points (Week 4, TE23).

What could hurt Theo Johnson's fantasy value?

Theo Johnson's risks: J.J. McCarthy has taken over at quarterback, so how the targets are shared is unsettled, the Jaguars in Week 11 (24th) and the Seahawks in Week 14 (25th) are tough matchups and he is TE2 on the depth chart. See his injury status and history.

How difficult is Theo Johnson's remaining fantasy schedule?

Difficult: of his next four games, zero come against a top-10 matchup for TEs and two against one of the stingiest defenses, by PPR points allowed to the position.

Is Theo Johnson a good fantasy playoff option?

His Weeks 15 to 17 opponents are the Browns (12th in points allowed to TEs), the Lions (1st in points allowed to TEs) and the Cowboys (17th in points allowed to TEs); one of them is favorable.