J.J. McCarthy Dynasty Profile

J.J. McCarthy is a 23-year-old quarterback for the New York Giants. On the StatChasers dynasty board he is valued at 1,040 in Superflex leagues, 124th overall and QB28 at his position, as of 2026-11-15. In completed dynasty startup drafts he goes 175.2 overall on average.

J.J. McCarthy Dynasty Trade Value & Rankings

Dynasty value (Superflex)
1,040
Overall rank
#124
Position rank
QB28
Startup ADP
175.2
Team
New York Giants
Age
23.0

J.J. McCarthy Startup ADP & Value Trends

Dynasty startup drafters take J.J. McCarthy 175.2 overall on average, later than his 124th place on the trade board, so drafts price him below what trades do. His value is up 55.0% over the last 30 days, +416 to 1,040. In 1QB leagues he is worth 311, 204th overall. His win-now value for this season is 881, close to his dynasty value: he fits a contender and a rebuild alike.

Players With Similar Dynasty Trade Values

The dynasty assets on either side of J.J. on the StatChasers board, as of 2026-11-15.

J.J. McCarthy Dynasty FAQ

What is J.J. McCarthy's dynasty trade value?

J.J. McCarthy is worth 1,040 on the StatChasers dynasty board in Superflex leagues and 311 in 1QB, which makes him the QB28 and 124th overall. That puts his price next to Malik Willis (1,166) and Kirk Cousins (1,000). His price is built from 795 completed dynasty trades that included him. Price a deal in the dynasty trade calculator.

Where does J.J. McCarthy rank in dynasty fantasy football?

In Superflex dynasty leagues J.J. McCarthy ranks 124th overall and QB28 at his position; in 1QB leagues he is 204th overall and QB33. At his position he sits between Malik Willis and Kirk Cousins. Superflex lifts him 80 spots against 1QB. Compare him with the full dynasty rankings.

Should I buy, sell, or hold J.J. McCarthy in dynasty?

The StatChasers market read has J.J. McCarthy as a clear buy right now at 1,040. At 23 his best years should be ahead of him; his value is up 55.0% (+416) over the last 30 days. Buyers can expect to pay below what his profile suggests. See who else is flagged on the buy low / sell high board.

What rookie draft picks is J.J. McCarthy worth?

In pick terms J.J. McCarthy's 1,040 Superflex value is closest to a 2029 Late 1st (1,558). Even the best single pick on the board, a 2027 Early 1st at 5,458, would cover more than his value on its own. Check a player-for-picks offer in the dynasty trade calculator.

Who should I trade J.J. McCarthy for in dynasty?

The players at other positions priced closest to J.J. McCarthy are Wan'Dale Robinson (WR, 975), DK Metcalf (WR, 1,115) and Kyle Pitts Sr. (TE, 1,133). Pick the one that fills your weakest starting spot. See what managers really paid for him in the dynasty trade database.

What is J.J. McCarthy worth in superflex dynasty leagues?

In Superflex leagues J.J. McCarthy is worth 1,040, 124th overall and QB28. In 1QB leagues the same player is worth 311 and ranks 204th overall. Starting a second quarterback makes him about 3.3 times as valuable, so check your league's format before you trade him. Set your league's format in the dynasty trade calculator.

Why is J.J. McCarthy's dynasty value rising?

J.J. McCarthy's value went from 624 to 1,040 over the last 30 days, a rise of 55.0%. StatChasers values follow completed dynasty trades, so the move reflects what managers have recently been willing to pay for him. See the trades behind it in the dynasty trade database, and his value chart on this page.

Is J.J. McCarthy a good dynasty asset for contenders or rebuilders?

J.J. McCarthy fits either plan. His 1,040 dynasty value and 881 win-now value are close, so he helps now without costing your future. As a 23-year-old QB, he has time on his side. Weigh him against your roster in the dynasty trade calculator.