J.J. McCarthy headshot

J.J. McCarthy 2026 Fantasy Outlook

#18 Quarterback

23 yrs 6'3", 219 lbs Michigan 3rd Season 2024 R1, P10

Giants#18QBActive

23 yrs6'3"219 lbs

Michigan

View fantasy profile

Fantasy · PPR

2026 Fantasy Season

10.6FPPG · PPRQB32POS RANK23%ROSTERED

2026 Regular Season

  • 915PASS YDS
  • 66/104CMP / ATT
  • 2PASS TD
  • 2INT
  • 90.0RATE
Next matchupWeek 11 vs. Jacksonville JaguarsSun Nov 22, 4:25 PM ET28th vs. QBs, toughView matchup

J.J. McCarthy Rest-of-Season Projection

QB3, waiver wireTough upcoming schedule

QB3, waiver wire, production in line with expectation.

  • McCarthy earns 9.4 expected PPR points a game. His 10.2 PPR points a game sit right at the 9.4 expected, so this is volume, not a hot streak.

  • Two of his next four opponents are among the stingiest defenses against QBs: the Jaguars in Week 11 (28th) and the Seahawks in Week 14 (31st). His role is what his fantasy value rides on, but difficult upcoming matchups make his near-term production less predictable.

What supports his value

Nothing in the usage data stands out yet.

What threatens his value

Two difficult matchups in his next four.

Opportunity vs. Production

Through Week 10, PPR. Expected points (xFP) is the fantasy value of the opportunities he is given; points over expected (FPOE) is what he has scored above or below that. Ranks are among qualifying QBs league-wide.

Production Efficiency
PPR points per game
10.2
Actual
Expected points per game
9.4
xFP
Points over expected
+0.8
per game
Opportunity Volume
Dropbacks per game
23.0
Designed-run rate
5.7%
Carries inside the 10
0

Production is running about at expectation.McCarthy's production is running right at expected (10.2 scored against 9.4 expected), so this is volume, not a hot streak.

Snap share has risen.His snap share is up 65 points over the same window (88% of snaps).

See the Giants usage report

What Drives J.J. McCarthy's Fantasy Value?

His 2026 rank through Week 10 among the quarterbacks who have played at least six games. Each row names its field. Each bar is one quarterback, best on the left; his is highlighted.

Passing volume

20.8attempts per game

Fewer than 6 games in 2026, so not ranked.

Efficiency

0.11EPA per play

Fewer than 6 games in 2026, so not ranked.

Rushing

17.0rush yards per game

Fewer than 6 games in 2026, so not ranked.

Expected points

9.4xFP per game

Fewer than 6 games in 2026, so not ranked.

Points over expected

Near expected
+0.8FPOE per game

Fewer than 6 games in 2026, so not ranked.

Success rate
38.7%
CPOE
+3.3
Sacks taken
10
Pressure rate
20.0%
Bad-throw rate
17.0%
Deep-attempt rate
16.7%

What Could Change His Value

Upside

  • More snaps88% of snaps over his last three games, up 65 points on Weeks 5-6.

Risk

  • Tough matchupsThe Jaguars in Week 11 (28th) and the Seahawks in Week 14 (31st) are among the stingiest defenses against QBs.
  • Pressure and sacks10 sacks and a 20.0% pressure rate in 2026.
Weighing McCarthy against another quarterback on your roster?Compare them in Redraft Command

J.J. McCarthy Upcoming Matchups

His next four opponents, ranked by PPR points allowed to QBs this season: 1st allows the most, 32nd the fewest.

  • Wk 11vs JAX28th vs QBsToughJacksonville Jaguars logo
  • Wk 12at IND17th vs QBsNeutralIndianapolis Colts logo
  • Wk 13vs SF16th vs QBsNeutralSan Francisco 49ers logo
  • Wk 14at SEA31st vs QBsToughSeattle Seahawks logo

A difficult stretch: two of the next four are bottom-10 matchups for QBs.

Fantasy playoffs (Weeks 15 to 17): vs Browns in Week 15 (25th), at Lions in Week 16 (1st) and at Cowboys in Week 17 (2nd); two favorable, one tough.

Read our preseason outlook (June 2026)

Published June 17, 2026. Kept for reference; the outlook above replaces it. Point totals in this piece are as published in June; the figures above are PPR points per game.

McCarthy's debut season offered little to build excitement on. Across 10 games he completed just 57.6% of his throws for 1,632 yards with 11 touchdowns against 12 interceptions, and the underlying numbers were uglier than the box score: a -0.151 EPA per play, a 41% success rate, and a -5.7 CPOE that pegged him as a clear negative as a passer. His 21.3% bad-throw rate and 51 poor throws underscore the accuracy concerns, though 181 rushing yards and four scores on 37 carries added a thin floor.

The bigger problem is opportunity. Minnesota brought in Kyler Murray, who profiles as the Week 1 favorite, pushing McCarthy toward QB36 territory with an ADP outside pick 270 and roster rates near 2.5%. The franchise still believes in him long-term, so he's a stash worth monitoring, but until the depth chart clears he's an afterthought in standard formats.

Keep researching Jj Mccarthy

J.J. McCarthy Fantasy Outlook FAQ

What is J.J. McCarthy's fantasy outlook for the rest of the 2026 season?

J.J. McCarthy projects as a qB3 for deep leagues only for the rest of the 2026 season: a streamer in superflex and 2QB leagues and waiver-wire material in 1QB leagues. His 10.2 PPR points a game match his 9.4 expected, so the production is the role. See his live rank in Redraft Command.

What is J.J. McCarthy's rest-of-season fantasy ranking?

J.J. McCarthy is the QB32 in PPR points per game through Week 10, and QB32 on the StatChasers rest-of-season board. That puts him in QB3 territory, waiver-wire material in 12-team 1QB leagues.

Should I buy low or sell high on J.J. McCarthy?

Neither: J.J. McCarthy's 10.2 PPR points a game sit close to his 9.4 expected, so his price matches his role. Hold him unless a trade fills a bigger need.

What is J.J. McCarthy's projected role going forward?

J.J. McCarthy is the listed starting QB, with Jameis Winston next on the depth chart. Nothing on the chart threatens the job, so the role is his to lose on performance.

Will J.J. McCarthy get more pass attempts?

J.J. McCarthy's pass attempts are trending up: 27.5 a game over his last two games against 20.8 for the season. Game script drives much of that, and trailing teams throw more.

What is J.J. McCarthy's fantasy football upside?

J.J. McCarthy's upside: his ceiling this season is 18.1 PPR points (Week 10, QB13).

What could hurt J.J. McCarthy's fantasy value?

J.J. McCarthy's risks: the Jaguars in Week 11 (28th) and the Seahawks in Week 14 (31st) are tough matchups. See his injury status and history.

How difficult is J.J. McCarthy's remaining fantasy schedule?

Difficult: of his next four games, zero come against a top-10 matchup for QBs and two against one of the stingiest defenses, by PPR points allowed to the position.

Is J.J. McCarthy a good fantasy playoff option?

His Weeks 15 to 17 opponents are the Browns (25th in points allowed to QBs), the Lions (1st in points allowed to QBs) and the Cowboys (2nd in points allowed to QBs); two of them are favorable.