Final/OT2023 · Week 13

Indianapolis Colts

AwayWon

31

Team hub
Scoring by quarter
TeamQ1Q2Q3Q4OTFinal
IND7693631
TEN10726328

Tennessee Titans

Home

28

Team hub
  • Sun, Dec 3, 2023 · 1:00 PM ET
  • CBS
  • Nissan Stadium, Tennessee
  • 62,641 attendance

Indianapolis Colts vs Tennessee Titans Match Player Stats: Week 13, 2023

Indianapolis Colts vs Tennessee Titans match player stats from Week 13 of the 2023 NFL season. The Colts defeated the Titans 31–28 in overtime on December 3, 2023.

IND 31TEN 28 Final/OT

Colts vs Titans Game Recap

The game's story, its leaders and the team stats.

  • Passing leader

    Gardner Minshew II

    IND · QB

    18.7PPR pts

    26/42, 312 YDS, 2 TD

  • Receiving leader

    Michael Pittman Jr.

    IND · WR

    27.5PPR pts

    11 REC, 105 YDS, 1 TD

  • Rushing leader

    Derrick Henry

    TEN · RB

    25.0PPR pts

    21 ATT, 102 YDS, 2 TD, 1 REC, 18 REC YDS

  • Defensive playmaker

    Grant Stuard

    IND

    1 TD

Colts 31, Titans 28: Indianapolis wins it in overtime

Indianapolis trailed 17–13 at halftime, regulation ended 25–25, and the Colts won it 31–28 in overtime. Tennessee outgained the Colts 381–355, but the Colts averaged 5.2 yards per play.

The Titans went 6-for-17 on third down and committed two turnovers.

The two teams meet again in Week 15 of 2026. If you roster anyone from either side, run the start/sit call in Redraft Command and it will weigh your lineup, your opponent and your league scoring, not only the player rankings.

Key advantages

  • +0.5 yards/play IND 5.2 · TEN 4.7

Official NFL highlights · Opens on YouTube

Got a Colt or Titan on your fantasy team?

Check their next matchup with the Start/Sit Tool, compare their value in the Fantasy Trade Calculator, or connect your league for personalized advice in Redraft Command.

Connect your league

Works with Sleeper, ESPN and Fleaflicker. No password needed.

Scoring Summary

The Colts scored three touchdowns and four field goals; the Titans scored four touchdowns and two field goals.

Scoring plays, Colts vs Titans
TimeTeamPlayINDTEN
1st quarter
13:20TENDerrick Henry 22-yard TD run Takes leadNick Folk XP07
12:05INDGardner Minshew → Alec Pierce, 36-yard TD Ties gameMatt Gay XP77
0:13TENNick Folk 24-yard FG Takes lead710
2nd quarter
10:22TENDerrick Henry 5-yard TD run Extends leadNick Folk XP717
7:39INDMatt Gay 23-yard FG1017
0:04INDMatt Gay 46-yard FG1317
3rd quarter
4:57INDMatt Gay 23-yard FG1617
0:19INDGrant Stuard 18-yard TD Takes lead2-pt try failed2217
0:19TENTitans TD Takes lead2223
4th quarter
11:34INDMatt Gay 28-yard FG Takes lead2523
5:26TENWill Levis → DeAndre Hopkins, 3-yard TD Takes leadXP missed2529
Overtime
4:19TENNick Folk 46-yard FG Extends lead2532
2:31INDGardner Minshew → Michael Pittman Jr., 4-yard TD3132

Colts vs Titans Box Score

Team stats, advanced efficiency and every player's passing, rushing, receiving, defense and special teams lines.

Colts vs Titans Team Stats

Team stats, Colts vs Titans
INDStatTEN
355Total yards381
5.2Yards / play4.7
2Turnovers2
0Interceptions thrown0
2Fumbles lost2
29:03Possession38:26
19First downs25
10Passing12
5Rushing12
4Penalty1
68Total plays81
300Passing yards204
26-42Comp-att16-33
6.7Yards / pass5.2
3-12Sacks-yards lost6-20
55Rushing yards177
23Rushing attempts42
2.4Yards / rush4.2
3-14 (21%)Third downs6-17 (35%)
1-1 (100%)Fourth downs0-1 (0%)
1-5 (20%)Red zone (TD-att)2-3 (67%)
4-29Penalties-yards9-74

Advanced Team Efficiency

Advanced team efficiency, Colts vs Titans
INDStatTEN
6.7Yards / dropback5.2
2.4Yards / carry4.2
About these numbers

EPA (expected points added) and success rate count pass and run plays, two-point tries left out; a successful play is one that adds expected points. Explosive plays gain 15+ yards on a dropback or 10+ on a run. QB hit rate is the share of the opponent's dropbacks that ended in a sack or a hit on the quarterback.

Passing

IND Indianapolis Colts passing
PlayerCMP/ATTCMP%YDSTDINTY/ARTG
Gardner Minshew II26/4261.9312207.4100.5
TEN Tennessee Titans passing
PlayerCMP/ATTCMP%YDSTDINTY/ARTG
Will Levis16/3348.5224106.880.9

Rushing

IND Indianapolis Colts rushing
PlayerATTYDSAVGTDLONG
Zack Moss19512.705
Kylen Granson122.002
Gardner Minshew II320.704
TEN Tennessee Titans rushing
PlayerATTYDSAVGTDLONG
Derrick Henry211024.9222
Tyjae Spears16754.7019
Will Levis252.506
DeAndre Hopkins144.004
Chig Okonkwo122.002
Ryan Stonehouse1-11-11.00-11

Receiving

IND Indianapolis Colts receiving
PlayerTGTRECYDSAVGTDLONG
Michael Pittman Jr.16111059.5114
Alec Pierce6310033.3155
Kylen Granson337224.0046
Josh Downs53144.709
Tyler Goodson22115.507
Zack Moss3263.005
Will Mallory4242.003
Trey Sermon1000.000
Drew Ogletree1000.000
TEN Tennessee Titans receiving
PlayerTGTRECYDSAVGTDLONG
DeAndre Hopkins1257515.0127
Chig Okonkwo636220.7039
Nick Westbrook-Ikhine312828.0028
Derrick Henry211818.0018
Josh Whyle211616.0016
Tyjae Spears64133.307
Chris Moore111212.0012
Trevon Wesco1000.000

Defense

IND Indianapolis Colts defense
PlayerTKLSACKSTFLPDINTFFFR
E.J. Speed8030000
Dayo Odeyingbo7000000
Julian Blackmon7000001
Kenny Moore II7000000
Kwity Paye6200000
Samson Ebukam6210000
DeForest Buckner60.501000
Jaylon Jones6001000
Zaire Franklin6000000
Darrell Baker Jr.5002000
Nick Cross5001000
Ronnie Harrison Jr.3000000
Tony Brown II3000000
Tyquan Lewis3010000
Segun Olubi2000001
Jacob Martin1100000
Eric Johnson II10.500000
Ryan Kelly1000000
Trevor Denbow1000000
TEN Tennessee Titans defense
PlayerTKLSACKSTFLPDINTFFFR
Jack Gibbens13001000
Azeez Al-Shaair12100000
Harold Landry III80.500000
Amani Hooker5002000
Roger McCreary5001000
Sean Murphy-Bunting5000000
Denico Autry4101000
Elijah Molden2000001
Jeffery Simmons2000000
K'Von Wallace2000000
Monty Rice2000000
Arden Key10.500000
Anthony Kendall1000000
Colton Dowell1000000
Jaleel Johnson1000000
Kristian Fulton1000000
Kyle Peko1001000
Rashad Weaver1000000
Teair Tart1000000
TK McLendon Jr.1000000
Tre Avery0001000

Special Teams

Kicking

IND Indianapolis Colts kicking
PlayerFGPCTLONGXPPTS
Matt Gay4/4100461/113
TEN Tennessee Titans kicking
PlayerFGPCTLONGXPPTS
Nick Folk2/2100462/38

Punting

IND Indianapolis Colts punting
PlayerNOYDSAVGTBIN 20LONG
Rigoberto Sanchez525651.20057
TEN Tennessee Titans punting
PlayerNOYDSAVGTBIN 20LONG
Ryan Stonehouse421854.51163
Nick Folk28140.50041

Kick returns

IND Indianapolis Colts kick returns
PlayerNOYDSAVGLONGTD
Isaiah McKenzie13636.0360
TEN Tennessee Titans kick returns
PlayerNOYDSAVGLONGTD
Tyjae Spears24020.0200

Punt returns

IND Indianapolis Colts punt returns
PlayerNOYDSAVGLONGTD
Isaiah McKenzie3258.3150
TEN Tennessee Titans punt returns
PlayerNOYDSAVGLONGTD
Eric Garror4369.0150

Colts vs Titans Fantasy Recap

The highlights, the fantasy box score, usage and opportunity, actual versus expected points, takeaways and next-week decisions.

Top Scorer

Michael Pittman Jr.

WR · IND · WR9 weekly finish

27.5fantasy points

11 catches for 105 yards and 1 touchdown on 16 targets. Commanded 39% of the Colts' targets.

Biggest Overperformer

Alec Pierce

WR · IND · WR13 weekly finish

19.0fantasy points

3 catches for 100 yards and 1 touchdown on 6 targets. Pierce got more out of the workload than it usually returns.

Biggest Underperformer

Zack Moss

RB · IND · RB27 weekly finish

7.7fantasy points

Despite 19 carries and 3 targets, Moss came up well short of what that workload is usually worth.

Fantasy Box Score

Fantasy points, weekly positional finish and game production for every offensive player
PlayerFPTSWeekly FinishGame Production
Michael Pittman Jr.WRIND27.5WR911 REC, 105 YDS, 1 TD, 16 TGT
Derrick HenryRBTEN25.0RB421 CAR, 102 RUSH YDS, 1 REC, 18 REC YDS, 2 TD
Alec PierceWRIND19.0WR133 REC, 100 YDS, 1 TD, 6 TGT
DeAndre HopkinsWRTEN18.9WR141 CAR, 4 RUSH YDS, 5 REC, 75 REC YDS, 1 TD
Gardner Minshew IIQBIND18.7QB12312 PASS YDS, 2 TD, 1 FUM LOST
Tyjae SpearsRBTEN12.8RB1616 CAR, 75 RUSH YDS, 4 REC, 13 REC YDS
Will LevisQBTEN11.5QB18224 PASS YDS, 1 TD, 1 FUM LOST
Kylen GransonTEIND10.4TE91 CAR, 2 RUSH YDS, 3 REC, 72 REC YDS
Chig OkonkwoTETEN9.4TE101 CAR, 2 RUSH YDS, 3 REC, 62 REC YDS
Zack MossRBIND7.7RB2719 CAR, 51 RUSH YDS, 2 REC, 6 REC YDS
Josh DownsWRIND4.4WR553 REC, 14 YDS, 5 TGT
Nick Westbrook-IkhineWRTEN3.8WR601 REC, 28 YDS, 3 TGT
Tyler GoodsonRBIND3.1RB422 REC, 11 YDS, 2 TGT
Josh WhyleTETEN2.6TE321 REC, 16 YDS, 2 TGT
Will MalloryTEIND2.4TE342 REC, 4 YDS, 4 TGT
Chris MooreWRTEN2.2WR711 REC, 12 YDS, 1 TGT
Drew OgletreeTEIND0.0-0 REC, 0 YDS, 1 TGT
Trevon WescoTETEN0.0-0 REC, 0 YDS, 1 TGT
Trey SermonRBIND0.0-0 REC, 0 YDS, 1 TGT
Ryan StonehouseTEN-3.1-1 CAR, -11 YDS, 1 FUM LOST

Usage & Opportunity

Indianapolis Colts

Indianapolis Colts snap, target and carry shares
PlayerSnap%Target%Carry%
Gardner Minshew IIQBIND100%-13%
Alec PierceWRIND99%15%-
Michael Pittman Jr.WRIND96%39%-
Zack MossRBIND94%7%83%
Josh DownsWRIND68%12%-
Drew OgletreeTEIND39%2%-
Kylen GransonTEIND34%7%4%
Will MalloryTEIND18%10%-
Tyler GoodsonRBIND4%5%-
Trey SermonRBIND1%2%-

Tennessee Titans

Tennessee Titans snap, target and carry shares
PlayerSnap%Target%Carry%
Will LevisQBTEN100%-5%
Nick Westbrook-IkhineWRTEN82%9%-
DeAndre HopkinsWRTEN76%36%2%
Chris MooreWRTEN69%3%-
Tyjae SpearsRBTEN67%18%38%
Chig OkonkwoTETEN59%18%2%
Trevon WescoTETEN54%3%-
Derrick HenryRBTEN40%6%50%
Josh WhyleTETEN26%6%-
Ryan StonehouseTEN--2%

Shares of each team's own snaps, targets and carries in this game. A dash means none recorded or not available.

Actual vs Expected (XFP)

  1. Alec PierceWRIND19.010.0+9.0 above expected

    6 targets were worth 10.0 points at league-average rates; the touchdown and above-average yardage added the other 9.0.

    Opportunity: 6 targets

  2. Zack MossRBIND7.716.7−9.0 below expected

    19 carries and 3 targets were worth 16.7 points at league-average rates.

    Opportunity: 19 carries and 3 targets

  3. Derrick HenryRBTEN25.016.2+8.8 above expected

    Touchdowns supplied 12.0 of the 25.0 points, the part least likely to repeat.

    Opportunity: 21 carries and 2 targets

  4. Tyjae SpearsRBTEN12.819.8−7.0 below expected

    16 carries and 6 targets were worth 19.8 points at league-average rates.

    Opportunity: 16 carries and 6 targets

  5. Kylen GransonTEIND10.45.6+4.8 above expected

    1 carry and 3 targets were worth 5.6 points at league-average rates; above-average yardage added the other 4.8.

    Opportunity: 1 carry and 3 targets

  6. Will MalloryTEIND2.46.7−4.3 below expected

    4 targets were worth 6.7 points at league-average rates.

    Opportunity: 4 targets

  7. Josh DownsWRIND4.48.3−3.9 below expected

    5 targets were worth 8.3 points at league-average rates.

    Opportunity: 5 targets

  8. Will LevisQBTEN11.515.1−3.6 below expected

    33 pass attempts and 2 carries were worth 15.1 points at league-average rates. Turnovers cost 2.0 of it.

    Opportunity: 33 pass attempts and 2 carries

  9. DeAndre HopkinsWRTEN18.920.6−1.7 in line

    The points matched the role: 1 carry and 12 targets worth 20.6 expected.

    Opportunity: 1 carry and 12 targets

  10. Nick Westbrook-IkhineWRTEN3.85.0−1.2 in line

    The points matched the role: 3 targets worth 5.0 expected.

    Opportunity: 3 targets

  11. Chig OkonkwoTETEN9.410.6−1.2 in line

    The points matched the role: 1 carry and 6 targets worth 10.6 expected.

    Opportunity: 1 carry and 6 targets

  12. Michael Pittman Jr.WRIND27.526.7+0.8 in line

    The points matched the role: 16 targets worth 26.7 expected.

    Opportunity: 16 targets

  13. Gardner Minshew IIQBIND18.719.5−0.8 in line

    The points matched the role: 42 pass attempts and 3 carries worth 19.5 expected.

    Opportunity: 42 pass attempts and 3 carries

  14. Josh WhyleTETEN2.63.3−0.7 in line

    The points matched the role: 2 targets worth 3.3 expected.

    Opportunity: 2 targets

  15. Tyler GoodsonRBIND3.13.3−0.2 in line

    The points matched the role: 2 targets worth 3.3 expected.

    Opportunity: 2 targets

xFP is what a player's opportunities were worth at league-average rates. A gap measures scoring above or below that workload, not necessarily the quality of the performance.

Fantasy Takeaways & Stock Changes

Zack Moss Stock Up

RB · IND

Played 94% of the snaps, up from a 56% season average. The role change matters more for future fantasy value than this game's 7.7 points. If the role holds, Moss is a start for the rest of the season.

Tyjae Spears Stock Up

RB · TEN

Led the Titans with 67% of the snaps and 38% of the carries, moving ahead of Derrick Henry. The role change matters more for future fantasy value than this game's 12.8 points. If the role holds, Spears is a start for the rest of the season.

Derrick Henry Stock Down

RB · TEN

Lost the backfield lead: 40% of the snaps to Tyjae Spears's 67%. The role change matters more for future fantasy value than this game's 25.0 points. Bench Henry for the rest of the season until the role comes back.

Michael Pittman Jr. Stock Up

WR · IND

16 targets is a season high. The clear first read: the next Colts target was Alec Pierce at 15%. If the role holds, Pittman is a start for the rest of the season.

Alec Pierce Sell High

WR · IND

Scored on a 6-touch role: a touchdown-or-bust profile. Sell-high window: don't count on the same touchdowns for the rest of the season.

Colts vs Titans Game Flow

How the game unfolded, possession by possession, and how each offense called it.

How the Game Swung

Tennessee opened at 50% win probability, climbed as high as >99%, then lost.

Titans win probability

Titans win probability by game minuteTitans started at 50%, stood at 66% at halftime and finished at 100%, across 13 scoring plays.

Key Swings

  1. +20Henry 22-yd TD run50% → 70%Q1 13:20
  2. +21Henry 5-yd TD run61% → 82%Q2 10:22
  3. −33Stuard 18-yd TD56% → 23%Q3 0:19
  4. +33Titans TD23% → 56%Q3 0:19
  5. +53Levis → Hopkins, 3-yd TD31% → 84%Q4 5:26

Swing in Titans win probability, in points

Play calling, Colts vs Titans
Indianapolis ColtsMeasureTennessee Titans
68Plays81
66%Pass rate48%
6.7Yds / dropback5.2
2.4Yds / carry4.2
3/14Third downs6/17

Efficiency edge Indianapolis ran 13 fewer plays but gained 1.5 more yards per dropback.

  • Top targets
  • IND Pittman 39% · Pierce 15% · Downs 12%
  • TEN Hopkins 36% · Okonkwo 18% · Spears 18%

Possession Results

How each possession ended, Colts vs Titans
ResultINDTEN
Touchdowns23
Field goals42
Punts57
Turnovers12

IND turnover edge: +1

  • The Titans opened the scoring on their first possession, a 4-play, 64-yard drive that ended in a touchdown.
All 28 possessions, drive by drive
Drive chart
TeamStartPlaysYardsTimeResult
TENQ1 15:004641:40Touchdown
INDQ1 13:203561:15Touchdown
TENQ1 12:058243:43Punt
INDQ1 8:22391:24Punt
TENQ1 6:585102:54Fumble
TENQ1 4:0410463:51Field goal
INDQ1 0:13350:32Punt
TENQ2 14:418774:19Touchdown
INDQ2 10:228702:43Field goal
TENQ2 7:39371:39Punt
INDQ2 6:0010804:12Fumble
TENQ2 1:48321:05Punt
INDQ2 0:436160:39Field goal
TENQ2 0:041-10:04End of half
INDQ3 15:00197010:03Field goal
TENQ3 4:57341:28Punt
INDQ3 3:29381:30Punt
TENQ3 1:59361:40Punt
TENQ3 0:194-141:37Fumble
INDQ4 13:424-32:08Field goal
TENQ4 11:3411756:08Touchdown
INDQ4 5:26331:22Punt
TENQ4 4:04481:37Punt
INDQ4 2:27391:14Punt
TENQ4 1:136191:00Punt
INDQ4 0:132-40:13End of half
TENOT 10:0010485:41Field goal
INDOT 4:195751:48Touchdown
About these numbers

The Colts' return touchdown is counted as a Titans possession, not as a Colts possession. Possessions that ended with the clock running out at the half or the end of the game aren't counted.

Personnel groupings, average depth of target and pass rate over expected appear when the tracking feed is connected.

Colts vs Titans Rivalry

The all-time series, recent meetings and both teams' seasons to date.

Season to Date Entering Week 13 (Through Week 12)

Season to date, Colts vs Titans
ColtsStatTitans
6-5Record4-7
24.5Points per game16.8
341.4Yards per game284.0
5.2Yards per play5.1
24.4Points allowed per game20.4
353.0Yards allowed per game335.4

Colts vs Titans Fantasy Outlook for 2026

One meeting is left on the 2026 schedule: Week 15 in Tennessee. Here's how to decide who to play in your league.

Colts vs Titans Game FAQ

Who won the 2023 Colts vs Titans Week 13 game?

The Indianapolis Colts beat the Tennessee Titans 31–28 in Week 13 of the 2023 season. The game was played at Nissan Stadium in Tennessee on December 3, 2023. See the Colts' 2023 schedule.

What was the final score of Colts vs Titans?

The final score was Colts 31, Titans 28 in overtime. The Titans led 17–13 at halftime, and the second half went Colts 12, Titans 8 before overtime.

What happened in the Colts vs Titans game?

Indianapolis trailed 17–13 at halftime, regulation ended 25–25, and the Colts won it 31–28 in overtime. Tennessee outgained the Colts 381–355, but the Colts averaged 5.2 yards per play. Michael Pittman Jr. led all players with 11 catches for 105 yards and a touchdown.

Who scored the most fantasy points in Colts vs Titans?

Michael Pittman Jr. led the game with 27.5 PPR fantasy points, the WR9 of Week 13, on 11 catches for 105 yards and a touchdown. Derrick Henry was next with 25.0 (RB4). See Michael Pittman Jr.'s 2023 game log.

Who led Colts vs Titans in passing, rushing and receiving?

Gardner Minshew II (IND) led all passers with 26 of 42 for 312 yards and 2 touchdowns. Derrick Henry (TEN) led in rushing with 21 carries for 102 yards and 2 touchdowns. Michael Pittman Jr. (IND) led in receiving with 11 catches for 105 yards and a touchdown.

How many fantasy points did Michael Pittman Jr. score against the Titans?

Michael Pittman Jr. scored 27.5 points in PPR leagues, 22.0 in half-PPR and 16.5 in standard scoring against the Titans in Week 13 of the 2023 season, on 11 catches for 105 yards and a touchdown. He drew 39% of his team's targets.

Who outperformed and underperformed expected fantasy points in Colts vs Titans?

Alec Pierce outperformed his expected fantasy points the most, scoring 19.0 PPR points on 10.0 xFP (+9.0). Zack Moss fell furthest short, with 7.7 points on 16.7 xFP (−9.0). A gap either way reflects efficiency and touchdowns in one game; it is not a forecast. For matchups ahead, see fantasy points allowed by position.

Who had the highest expected fantasy points in Colts vs Titans?

Michael Pittman Jr. had the most fantasy opportunity in the game, worth 26.7 expected PPR points (xFP) at league-average rates, and scored 27.5. Expected points measure the volume of a player's pass attempts, carries and targets, not how well he used them.

How did the Colts beat the Titans?

The Colts beat the Titans 31–28 because they averaged 5.2 yards per play to 4.7.

What is the all-time Colts vs Titans record?

The Colts lead the all-time series 41–23 across 64 meetings since 1970, including a 0–1 record in the postseason.

When did the Colts and Titans last play before this game?

Before Week 13 of 2023, they last met in the 2023 season on October 8, 2023, when the Colts beat the Titans 23–16.

Have the Colts and Titans met in the playoffs?

Yes, 1 time, most recently in the 1999 playoffs. The Colts are 0–1 against the Titans in the postseason.

What is the Colts vs Titans record since 2021?

The Colts lead 6–5 across 11 meetings since the 2021 season, including this game.

Set your lineup for this game