Final/OT2023 Week 13

Nissan Stadium, Nashville, TN

Indianapolis Colts vs Tennessee Titans, Week 13 2023

Indianapolis Colts

AwayWon

31

Tennessee Titans

Home

28

Scoring by quarter
TeamQ1Q2Q3Q4OTFinal
Colts7693631
Titans10726328

IND 31TEN 28 Final/OT

  • Passing leader

    Gardner Minshew II

    IND · QB

    18.7PPR pts

    26/42, 312 YDS, 2 TD

  • Top fantasy scorer

    Michael Pittman Jr.

    IND · WR

    27.5PPR pts

    11 REC, 105 YDS, 1 TD

  • Titans leader

    Derrick Henry

    TEN · RB

    25.0PPR pts

    21 ATT, 102 YDS, 2 TD, 1 REC, 18 REC YDS

  • Defensive playmaker

    Grant Stuard

    IND

    1 TD

Colts 31, Titans 28: Indianapolis wins it in overtime

Indianapolis trailed 17–13 at halftime, regulation ended 25–25, and the Colts won it 31–28 in overtime. Tennessee outgained the Colts 381–355, but the Colts averaged 5.2 yards per play.

The Titans went 6-for-17 on third down and committed two turnovers.

The two teams meet again in Week 6 of 2026. If you roster anyone from either side, run the start/sit call in Redraft Command and it will weigh your lineup, your opponent and your league scoring, not only the player rankings.

Key advantages

  • +0.5 yards/play IND 5.2 · TEN 4.7

Game Highlights

Official NFL highlights · Opens from YouTube

Got a Colt or Titan on your fantasy team?

Check their next matchup with the Start/Sit Tool, compare their value in the Fantasy Trade Calculator, or connect your league for personalized advice in Redraft Command.

Connect your league

Works with Sleeper, ESPN and Fleaflicker. No password needed.

Why the Colts Won

Indianapolis won the efficiency battle.

Team stats comparison, Colts vs Titans
ColtsStatTitans
5.2Yards per play4.7
Other team stats
355Total yards381
68Plays81
2Turnovers2
21%Third-down conversion35%
29:03Time of possession38:26

Scoring Summary

The Colts scored three touchdowns and four field goals; the Titans scored four touchdowns and two field goals.

Scoring plays, Colts vs Titans
TimeTeamPlayINDTEN
1st quarter
13:20TENDerrick Henry 22-yard TD run Takes leadNick Folk XP07
12:05INDGardner Minshew → Alec Pierce, 36-yard TD Ties gameMatt Gay XP77
0:13TENNick Folk 24-yard FG Takes lead710
2nd quarter
10:22TENDerrick Henry 5-yard TD run Extends leadNick Folk XP717
7:39INDMatt Gay 23-yard FG1017
0:04INDMatt Gay 46-yard FG1317
3rd quarter
4:57INDMatt Gay 23-yard FG1617
0:19INDGrant Stuard 18-yard TD Takes lead2-pt try failed2217
0:19TENTitans TD Takes lead2223
4th quarter
11:34INDMatt Gay 28-yard FG Takes lead2523
5:26TENWill Levis → DeAndre Hopkins, 3-yard TD Takes leadXP missed2529
Overtime
4:19TENNick Folk 46-yard FG Extends lead2532
2:31INDGardner Minshew → Michael Pittman Jr., 4-yard TD3132

Fantasy Points: Colts vs Titans, Week 13 2023

Fantasy leaders

  1. Michael PittmanINDWR27.5 PTSWR9
  2. Derrick HenryTENRB25.0 PTSRB4
  3. Alec PierceINDWR19.0 PTSWR13
  4. DeAndre HopkinsTENWR18.9 PTSWR14

Player Stats

Quarterbacks

Quarterback statistics
PlayerFPTSFINCMP/ATTPass YDSTDINTRush ATTRush YDSRush TDRateStart/Sit
Gardner MinshewINDQB18.7QB1226/4231220320100.5
Will LevisTENQB13.5QB1716/332241025080.9

WRs, RBs, & TEs

Receiver, running back and tight end statistics
PlayerFPTSFINPOSRush ATTRush YDSRush TDTGTRECRec YDSRec TDStart/Sit
Michael PittmanINDWR27.5WR9WR———16111051
Derrick HenryTENRB25.0RB4RB21102221180Start/Sit →
Alec PierceINDWR19.0WR13WR———631001
DeAndre HopkinsTENWR18.9WR14WR140125751
Tyjae SpearsTENRB12.8RB16RB1675064130Start/Sit →
Kylen GransonINDTE10.4TE9TE12033720Start/Sit →
Chig OkonkwoTENTE9.4TE11TE12063620Start/Sit →
Zack MossINDRB7.7RB27RB195103260
Josh DownsINDWR4.4WR55WR———53140Start/Sit →
Nick Westbrook-IkhineTENWR3.8WR60WR———31280Start/Sit →
Tyler GoodsonINDRB3.1RB42RB———22110Start/Sit →
Josh WhyleTENTE2.6TE33TE———21160Start/Sit →
Will MalloryINDTE2.4TE34TE———4240
Chris MooreTENWR2.2WR71WR———11120Start/Sit →
Trevon WescoTENTE0.0—TE———1000
Trey SermonINDRB0.0—RB———1000
Drew OgletreeINDTE0.0—TE———1000Start/Sit →

Fantasy Usage

Indianapolis Colts

Snap Share

  1. Alec PierceWR70 snaps99%
  2. Michael PittmanWR68 snaps96%
  3. Zack MossRB67 snaps94%
  4. Josh DownsWR48 snaps68%
  5. Drew OgletreeTE28 snaps39%

Target Share41 targets

  1. Michael Pittman39%, 16 targets
  2. Alec Pierce15%, 6 targets
  3. Josh Downs12%, 5 targets
  4. Will Mallory10%, 4 targets
  5. Zack Moss7%, 3 targets
  6. Other17%, 7 targets

Carry Share23 carries

  1. Zack Moss83%, 19 carries
  2. Gardner Minshew13%, 3 carries
  3. Kylen Granson4%, 1 carries

Tennessee Titans

Snap Share

  1. Nick Westbrook-IkhineWR70 snaps82%
  2. DeAndre HopkinsWR65 snaps76%
  3. Chris MooreWR59 snaps69%
  4. Tyjae SpearsRB57 snaps67%
  5. Chig OkonkwoTE50 snaps59%

Target Share33 targets

  1. DeAndre Hopkins36%, 12 targets
  2. Chig Okonkwo18%, 6 targets
  3. Tyjae Spears18%, 6 targets
  4. Nick Westbrook-Ikhine9%, 3 targets
  5. Derrick Henry6%, 2 targets
  6. Other12%, 4 targets

Carry Share41 carries

  1. Derrick Henry51%, 21 carries
  2. Tyjae Spears39%, 16 carries
  3. Will Levis5%, 2 carries
  4. DeAndre Hopkins2%, 1 carries
  5. Chig Okonkwo2%, 1 carries
View full usage tableHide full usage table
Offensive snaps and share for the skill positions
PlayerSNAPSSNAP %TGTTGT %CAR
Alec PierceINDWR7099%615%0
Michael PittmanINDWR6896%1639%0
Zack MossINDRB6794%37%19
Nick Westbrook-IkhineTENWR7082%39%0
DeAndre HopkinsTENWR6576%1236%1
Chris MooreTENWR5969%13%0
Josh DownsINDWR4868%512%0
Tyjae SpearsTENRB5767%618%16
Chig OkonkwoTENTE5059%618%1
Trevon WescoTENTE4654%13%0
Derrick HenryTENRB3440%26%21
Drew OgletreeINDTE2839%12%0
Mo Alie-CoxINDTE2434%00%0
Kylen GransonINDTE2434%37%1
Josh WhyleTENTE2226%26%0
Will MalloryINDTE1318%410%0
Treylon BurksTENWR1012%00%0
Kevin RaderTENTE911%00%0
Isaiah McKenzieINDWR68%00%0
D.J. MontgomeryINDWR34%00%0
Tyler GoodsonINDRB34%25%0
Colton DowellTENWR34%00%0
Trey SermonINDRB11%12%0

Fantasy Points vs Expected

Expected points (xFP) are what a player's pass attempts, carries and targets are worth at the league's average rates; the difference is what the player made of them.

  • Biggest overperformer+9.0Alec Pierce19.0 PTS vs 10.0 xFP
  • Biggest underperformer−9.0Zack Moss7.7 PTS vs 16.7 xFP
  • Highest expected volume26.7 xFPMichael Pittman Jr.27.5 PTS scored
Usage and expected fantasy points
PlayerPTSxFPvs xFPSnap%UsageRte%Pass attCarCar%TgtTgt%
Michael Pittman Jr.IND · WR27.526.7+0.896%39% tgt—000%1639%
DeAndre HopkinsTEN · WR18.920.7−1.876%36% tgt—012%1236%
Tyjae SpearsTEN · RB12.819.8−7.067%38% car—01638%618%
Gardner Minshew IIIND · QB18.719.5−0.8100%42 att—42313%00%
Zack MossIND · RB7.716.7−9.094%83% car—01983%37%
Derrick HenryTEN · RB25.016.2+8.840%50% car—02150%26%
Will LevisTEN · QB11.515.1−3.6100%33 att—3325%00%
Chig OkonkwoTEN · TE9.410.6−1.259%18% tgt—012%618%
Alec PierceIND · WR19.010.0+9.099%15% tgt—000%615%
Josh DownsIND · WR4.48.3−3.968%12% tgt—000%512%
Will MalloryIND · TE2.46.7−4.318%10% tgt—000%410%
Kylen GransonIND · TE10.45.6+4.834%7% tgt—014%37%
Nick Westbrook-IkhineTEN · WR3.85.0−1.282%9% tgt—000%39%
Josh WhyleTEN · TE2.63.3−0.726%6% tgt—000%26%
Tyler GoodsonIND · RB3.13.3−0.24%5% tgt—000%25%
Chris MooreTEN · WR2.21.7+0.569%3% tgt—000%13%
Drew OgletreeIND · TE0.01.7−1.739%2% tgt—000%12%
Trevon WescoTEN · TE0.01.7−1.754%3% tgt—000%13%
Trey SermonIND · RB0.01.7−1.71%2% tgt—000%12%
Ryan StonehouseTEN · —-3.10.6−3.7—2% car—012%00%

Team totals: Colts 41 targets and 23 carries; Titans 33 targets and 42 carries. Shares are from the box score. Snap counts are from the weekly player logs (Sleeper), and include plays wiped out by penalties. Route counts, air yards and red-zone touches appear when the tracking feed is connected. League-average rates from the 2023 season: 1.67 PPR points per target (67% catch rate), 0.61 per carry and 0.42 per pass attempt. They don't adjust for field position or target depth.

Fantasy Verdicts

Gardner Minshew II

IND · QB · 18.7 pts on 19.5 expected

26 of 42 passing for 312 yards, 2 touchdowns; 3 carries for 2 yards.

Verdict: The points matched the role, 19.5 expected.

Will Levis

TEN · QB · 11.5 pts on 15.1 expected

16 of 33 passing for 224 yards, 1 touchdown; 2 carries for 5 yards.

Verdict: The points matched the role, 15.1 expected.

Michael Pittman Jr. Strong role

IND · WR · 27.5 pts on 26.7 expected

16 targets (39% of the team's), 11 catches for 105 yards and 1 touchdown.

Verdict: The points matched the role, 26.7 expected.

Zack Moss Volume, no payoff

IND · RB · 7.7 pts on 16.7 expected

3 targets (7% of the team's), 2 catches for 6 yards; 19 carries (83% of the team's) for 51 yards.

Verdict: The role was there, worth 16.7 points at league-average rates; the production wasn't.

DeAndre Hopkins Volume, no payoff

TEN · WR · 18.9 pts on 20.7 expected

12 targets (36% of the team's), 5 catches for 75 yards and 1 touchdown; 1 carry (2% of the team's) for 4 yards.

Verdict: The points matched the role, 20.7 expected.

Tyjae Spears Unlucky

TEN · RB · 12.8 pts on 19.8 expected

6 targets (18% of the team's), 4 catches for 13 yards; 16 carries (38% of the team's) for 75 yards.

Verdict: The role was there, worth 19.8 points at league-average rates; the production wasn't.

Start/Sit: Tyjae Spears →

Derrick Henry Ran hot

TEN · RB · 25.0 pts on 16.2 expected

2 targets (6% of the team's), 1 catch for 18 yards; 21 carries (50% of the team's) for 102 yards and 2 touchdowns.

Verdict: The opportunities were worth 16.2 points; the touchdowns supplied the rest, and they are the part least likely to repeat.

Start/Sit: Derrick Henry →

Alec Pierce Ran hot

IND · WR · 19.0 pts on 10.0 expected

6 targets (15% of the team's), 3 catches for 100 yards and 1 touchdown.

Verdict: The opportunities were worth 10.0 points; the touchdowns supplied the rest, and they are the part least likely to repeat.

Stock Up, Stock Down

Indianapolis Colts

  • Stock up: Zack Moss played 94% of the snaps, up from a 56% season average.
  • Stock down: Kylen Granson played 34% of the snaps, down from a 53% season average.

Tennessee Titans

  • Stock up: Tyjae Spears led the backfield with 67% of the snaps after trailing Derrick Henry before this game.
  • Stock up: Chris Moore played 69% of the snaps, up from a 53% season average.
  • Stock down: Derrick Henry lost the backfield lead: 40% of the snaps to Tyjae Spears's 67%.

Fantasy Matchups

Fantasy points allowed per game by position, 2023 through Week 18.

Fantasy points allowed per game by position, Colts defense and Titans defense
Points allowed toColts DTitans D
QBs15.915.6
RBs26.118.6
WRs31.636.8
TEs12.99.7

Regular season, summed from each game's box score and scored with this page's rules.

How the Game Swung

Tennessee opened at 50% win probability, climbed as high as >99%, then lost.

Titans win probability

Titans win probability by game minuteTitans started at 50%, stood at 66% at halftime and finished at 100%, across 13 scoring plays.Q1Q2Q3Q4OT100%50%0%

Key Swings

  1. +20Henry 22-yd TD run50% → 70%Q1 13:20
  2. +21Henry 5-yd TD run61% → 82%Q2 10:22
  3. −33Stuard 18-yd TD56% → 23%Q3 0:19
  4. +33Titans TD23% → 56%Q3 0:19
  5. +53Levis → Hopkins, 3-yd TD31% → 84%Q4 5:26

Swing in Titans win probability, in points

Play Calling and Possessions

Play calling, Colts vs Titans
Indianapolis ColtsMeasureTennessee Titans
68Plays81
66%Pass rate48%
6.7Yds / dropback5.2
2.4Yds / carry4.2
3/14Third downs6/17

Efficiency edge Indianapolis ran 13 fewer plays but gained 1.5 more yards per dropback.

  • Top targets
  • IND Pittman 39% · Pierce 15% · Downs 12%
  • TEN Hopkins 36% · Okonkwo 18% · Spears 18%

Possession Results

How each possession ended, Colts vs Titans
ResultINDTEN
Touchdowns23
Field goals42
Punts57
Turnovers12

IND turnover edge: +1

  • The Titans opened the scoring on their first possession, a 4-play, 64-yard drive that ended in a touchdown.
All 28 possessions, drive by drive
Drive chart
TeamStartPlaysYardsTimeResult
TENQ1 15:004641:40Touchdown
INDQ1 13:203561:15Touchdown
TENQ1 12:058243:43Punt
INDQ1 8:22391:24Punt
TENQ1 6:585102:54Fumble
TENQ1 4:0410463:51Field goal
INDQ1 0:13350:32Punt
TENQ2 14:418774:19Touchdown
INDQ2 10:228702:43Field goal
TENQ2 7:39371:39Punt
INDQ2 6:0010804:12Fumble
TENQ2 1:48321:05Punt
INDQ2 0:436160:39Field goal
TENQ2 0:041-10:04End of half
INDQ3 15:00197010:03Field goal
TENQ3 4:57341:28Punt
INDQ3 3:29381:30Punt
TENQ3 1:59361:40Punt
TENQ3 0:194-141:37Fumble
INDQ4 13:424-32:08Field goal
TENQ4 11:3411756:08Touchdown
INDQ4 5:26331:22Punt
TENQ4 4:04481:37Punt
INDQ4 2:27391:14Punt
TENQ4 1:136191:00Punt
INDQ4 0:132-40:13End of half
TENOT 10:0010485:41Field goal
INDOT 4:195751:48Touchdown
About these numbers

The Colts' return touchdown is counted as a Titans possession, not as a Colts possession. Possessions that ended with the clock running out at the half or the end of the game aren't counted.

Personnel groupings, average depth of target and pass rate over expected appear when the tracking feed is connected.

Colts vs Titans Head-to-Head

The Colts and Titans first met in 1970 and have played 63 times since. They have been AFC South rivals since 2002.

All-time series
41–22Colts lead, 63 meetings since 1970
Postseason
1–0Titans won in 1999
Largest Colts win
35–32005
Largest Titans win
45–262020

Since 2021

6–4 Colts lead

10 meetings since the 2021 season, regular season and playoffs.

Oldest to newest. C = Colts win, T = Titans win, outlined = this game.

2026 Meetings

  • Week 6 Titans at Colts Upcoming
  • Week 15 Colts at Titans Upcoming

Recent Meetings

Season to Date (Through Week 18)

The 2023 regular season, from each game's box score.

Season to date, Colts vs Titans
ColtsStatTitans
9-8Record6-11
23.3Points per game17.9
336.8Yards per game289.0
5.2Yards per play4.9
24.4Points allowed per game21.6
349.8Yards allowed per game335.1

Colts vs Titans Fantasy Outlook for 2026

Two meetings are left on the 2026 schedule: Week 6 in Indianapolis and Week 15 in Tennessee. Here's how to decide who to play in your league.

Keep Exploring

2023 Game Logs for Players in This Game

Colts vs Titans Game FAQ

Who won the 2023 Colts vs Titans Week 13 game?

The Indianapolis Colts beat the Tennessee Titans 31–28 in Week 13 of the 2023 season. The game was played at Nissan Stadium in Nashville, TN, on December 3, 2023. See the Colts' 2023 schedule.

What was the final score of Colts vs Titans?

The final score was Colts 31, Titans 28 in overtime. The Titans led 17–13 at halftime, and the second half went Colts 12, Titans 8 before overtime.

What happened in the Colts vs Titans game?

Indianapolis trailed 17–13 at halftime, regulation ended 25–25, and the Colts won it 31–28 in overtime. Tennessee outgained the Colts 381–355, but the Colts averaged 5.2 yards per play. Michael Pittman led all players with 11 catches for 105 yards and a touchdown.

Who scored the most fantasy points in Colts vs Titans?

Michael Pittman led the game with 27.5 PPR fantasy points, the WR9 of Week 13, on 11 catches for 105 yards and a touchdown. Derrick Henry was next with 25.0 (RB4). See Michael Pittman's 2023 game log.

Who led Colts vs Titans in passing, rushing and receiving?

Gardner Minshew (IND) led all passers with 26 of 42 for 312 yards and 2 touchdowns. Derrick Henry (TEN) led in rushing with 21 carries for 102 yards and 2 touchdowns. Michael Pittman (IND) led in receiving with 11 catches for 105 yards and a touchdown.

How many fantasy points did Michael Pittman score against the Titans?

Michael Pittman scored 27.5 points in PPR leagues, 22.0 in half-PPR and 16.5 in standard scoring against the Titans in Week 13 of the 2023 season, on 11 catches for 105 yards and a touchdown.

Who outperformed and underperformed expected fantasy points in Colts vs Titans?

Alec Pierce outperformed his expected fantasy points the most, scoring 19.0 PPR points on 10.0 xFP (+9.0). Zack Moss fell furthest short, with 7.7 points on 16.7 xFP (−9.0). A gap either way reflects efficiency and touchdowns in one game; it is not a forecast. For matchups ahead, see fantasy points allowed by position.

Who had the highest expected fantasy points in Colts vs Titans?

Michael Pittman Jr. had the most fantasy opportunity in the game, worth 26.7 expected PPR points (xFP) at league-average rates, and scored 27.5. Expected points measure the volume of a player's pass attempts, carries and targets, not how well he used them.

How did the Colts beat the Titans?

The Colts beat the Titans 31–28 because they averaged 5.2 yards per play to 4.7.

What is the all-time Colts vs Titans record?

The Colts lead the all-time series 41–22 across 63 meetings since 1970, including a 0–1 record in the postseason.

When did the Colts and Titans last play before this game?

Before Week 13 of 2023, they last met in the 2023 season on October 8, 2023, when the Colts beat the Titans 23–16.

Have the Colts and Titans met in the playoffs?

Yes, 1 time, most recently in the 1999 playoffs. The Colts are 0–1 against the Titans in the postseason.

What is the Colts vs Titans record since 2021?

The Colts lead 6–4 across 10 meetings since the 2021 season, including this game.