J.J. McCarthy Dynasty Value 2026
J.J. McCarthy dynasty outlook: superflex and 1QB value, dynasty rank, age curve, startup and rookie draft cost, long-term market trend, production history and trade context.
J.J. McCarthy dynasty outlook
J.J. McCarthy is ranked #155 overall and QB31 in StatChasers' superflex dynasty rankings, a deep-roster or taxi-squad option at a market value of 715.
He is 23.0 years old — early in a quarterback's dynasty window, which is the longest of any position. Age is weighted per position in the model value, so this is priced in rather than mentioned in passing.
Format matters here: J.J. is worth 715 in superflex against 94 in 1QB, a +660.6% difference — the usual superflex quarterback premium. Check which format a comparable trade came from before using it as a price.
The model values J.J. +310.6% above the dynasty market, a buy-low signal: his production and age say the price is too low.
In dynasty startup drafts J.J. goes at pick 176.7 on average (round 15.09 in a 12-team startup, QB34 by ADP), with a typical range of 127 to 222 across 815 drafts; his startup cost is falling over the last 30 days (-38.0 picks).
Over the longer run his startup ADP has fallen: from an average pick of 151.9 in 2024-02 to 227.1 in 2026-09, across 27 months of drafts.
One season on record: 13.7 PPR points per game across 10 games in 2025, a QB30 finish.
Drafted round 1, pick 10 by Minnesota Vikings in 2024. Draft capital keeps mattering in dynasty long after it stops mattering in redraft — teams keep giving opportunity to players they spent a pick on.
Player profile
| Team | New York Giants |
| Position | QB |
| Age | 23.0 |
| Experience | 2 yrs |
| Number | #18 |
| Bye week | Week 8 |
| Status | Active |
Dynasty value
| Superflex value (StatChasers Market) | 715 |
| Superflex rank | #155 · QB31 |
| 1QB value | 94 |
| 1QB rank | #282 · QB31 |
| 30-day movement | — |
| Win-now (redraft) value | — |
| Timeline | — |
| Model value | 2,936 |
| Model vs market | +310.6% |
| Signal | Strong Buy |
Run a trade with J.J. in the dynasty trade calculator, or find one with the dynasty trade finder.
J.J. McCarthy startup draft cost
Drafted in 815 completed dynasty startup drafts · overall ADP rank #176 · QB34 · earliest pick 33, latest 290 · 7-day -21.0, 14-day -20.0. Full board on the dynasty startup rankings page.
J.J. McCarthy dynasty value trend
Average startup-draft pick by month, oldest to newest — a taller bar is an earlier pick and a more valuable player. Months with fewer than three completed drafts are omitted. Range over this window: pick 44.3 to 227.1.
J.J. McCarthy production by season
Career production, which in dynasty is read as a trajectory rather than a snapshot: the direction across seasons matters more than any single line.
| Season | Team | Games | PPR / game | Half / game | Std / game | PPR finish | Half finish |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | MIN | 10 | 13.7 | 13.7 | 13.7 | QB30 | QB30 |
J.J. McCarthy draft capital and athletic profile
Combine measurements with the percentile against other QBs in the database. Athletic profile and draft capital are long-horizon inputs — they say little about next Sunday and a good deal about how long a team keeps handing a player opportunity.
Draft capital
| Draft class | 2024 |
| Round | 1 |
| Overall pick | #10 |
| Drafted by | Minnesota Vikings |
| Height | 6'3" |
| Weight | 219 lb |
Combine testing
Bar length is the percentile against the position cohort.
Dynasty assets valued near J.J. McCarthy
Same position, nearest dynasty value — the players he is realistically swapped for.
Use J.J. in the dynasty tools
Is J.J. on your dynasty roster?
Connect your league and Dynasty Command shows who owns J.J. McCarthy, what he is worth in your exact format, whether he fits your contention window, and which managers in your league would trade for him.
Open J.J. in Dynasty Command →All StatChasers dynasty tools
Data on this page updated 2026-09-30.