Final2025 · Week 16

Buffalo Bills

AwayWon

23

Team hub
Scoring by quarter
TeamQ1Q2Q3Q4Final
BUF7133023
CLE737320

Cleveland Browns

Home

20

Team hub
  • Sun, Dec 21, 2025 · 1:00 PM ET
  • CBS
  • FirstEnergy Stadium, Cleveland
  • 67,580 attendance

Buffalo Bills vs Cleveland Browns Match Player Stats: Week 16, 2025

Buffalo Bills vs Cleveland Browns match player stats from Week 16 of the 2025 NFL season. The Bills defeated the Browns 23–20 on December 21, 2025.

BUF 23CLE 20 Final

Bills vs Browns Game Recap

The game's story, its leaders and the team stats.

  • Passing leader

    Shedeur Sanders

    CLE · QB

    13.2PPR pts

    20/29, 157 YDS, 1 TD, 2 INT

  • Receiving leader

    Trayveon Williams

    CLE · RB

    9.5PPR pts

    4 REC, 38 YDS

  • Rushing leader

    James Cook III

    BUF · RB

    26.4PPR pts

    16 ATT, 117 YDS, 2 TD, 1 REC, 17 REC YDS

  • Defensive playmaker

    Jordan Poyer

    BUF

    1 INT, 0.5 SACK, 11 TKL

Bills 23, Browns 20: Buffalo holds off Cleveland

Buffalo led 20–10 at halftime and won 23–20, though Cleveland took the second half 10–3. Cleveland outgained the Bills 294–259, but the Bills averaged 5.2 yards per play.

The Browns went 8-for-14 on third down and committed two turnovers, while the Bills finished without a giveaway.

Key advantages

  • +0.6 yards/play BUF 5.2 · CLE 4.6
  • +2 turnover margin BUF 0 turnovers

Official NFL highlights · Opens on YouTube

Got a Bill or Brown on your fantasy team?

Check their next matchup with the Start/Sit Tool, compare their value in the Fantasy Trade Calculator, or connect your league for personalized advice in Redraft Command.

Connect your league

Works with Sleeper, ESPN and Fleaflicker. No password needed.

Scoring Summary

The Bills scored three touchdowns and one field goal; the Browns scored two touchdowns and two field goals.

Scoring plays, Bills vs Browns
TimeTeamPlayBUFCLE
1st quarter
10:42CLEShedeur Sanders → Harold Fannin Jr., 13-yard TD Takes leadAndre Szmyt XP07
7:47BUFJames Cook III 44-yard TD run Ties gameMichael Badgley XP77
2nd quarter
12:54BUFTy Johnson 2-yard TD run Takes leadXP missed137
5:38CLEAndre Szmyt 24-yard FG1310
2:23BUFJames Cook III 3-yard TD run Extends leadMichael Badgley XP2010
3rd quarter
9:37BUFMichael Badgley 41-yard FG Extends lead2310
1:36CLEHarold Fannin Jr. 1-yard TD runAndre Szmyt XP2317
4th quarter
8:46CLEAndre Szmyt 41-yard FG2320

Bills vs Browns Box Score

Team stats, advanced efficiency and every player's passing, rushing, receiving, defense and special teams lines.

Bills vs Browns Team Stats

Team stats, Bills vs Browns
BUFStatCLE
259Total yards294
5.2Yards / play4.6
0Turnovers2
0Interceptions thrown2
0Fumbles lost0
24:37Possession35:23
16First downs22
6Passing8
10Rushing12
0Penalty2
50Total plays64
95Passing yards134
12-19Comp-att20-30
4.5Yards / pass4.1
2-35Sacks-yards lost3-23
164Rushing yards160
29Rushing attempts31
5.7Yards / rush5.2
2-8 (25%)Third downs8-14 (57%)
0-2 (0%)Fourth downs0-1 (0%)
2-3 (67%)Red zone (TD-att)2-4 (50%)
5-35Penalties-yards5-44

Advanced Team Efficiency

Advanced team efficiency, Bills vs Browns
BUFStatCLE
4.5Yards / dropback4.1
5.7Yards / carry5.2
About these numbers

EPA (expected points added) and success rate count pass and run plays, two-point tries left out; a successful play is one that adds expected points. Explosive plays gain 15+ yards on a dropback or 10+ on a run. QB hit rate is the share of the opponent's dropbacks that ended in a sack or a hit on the quarterback.

Passing

BUF Buffalo Bills passing
PlayerCMP/ATTCMP%YDSTDINTY/ARTG
Josh Allen12/1963.2130006.883.2
CLE Cleveland Browns passing
PlayerCMP/ATTCMP%YDSTDINTY/ARTG
Shedeur Sanders20/2969.0157125.464.9
Corey Bojorquez0/10.00000.039.6
Dillon Gabriel0/0-0000.00.0

Rushing

BUF Buffalo Bills rushing
PlayerATTYDSAVGTDLONG
James Cook III161177.3244
Josh Allen7172.407
Ty Johnson3165.319
Ray Davis3144.708
CLE Cleveland Browns rushing
PlayerATTYDSAVGTDLONG
Shedeur Sanders44912.3016
Raheim Sanders11423.809
Malachi Corley33010.0014
Quinshon Judkins8222.805
Trayveon Williams3175.7011
Harold Fannin Jr.111.011
Isaiah Bond1-1-1.00-1

Receiving

BUF Buffalo Bills receiving
PlayerTGTRECYDSAVGTDLONG
Khalil Shakir54348.5018
Jackson Hawes222613.0018
Tyrell Shavers212121.0021
Ray Davis222010.0014
James Cook III211717.0017
Dawson Knox211010.0010
Joshua Palmer1122.002
Brandin Cooks1000.000
Dalton Kincaid1000.000
CLE Cleveland Browns receiving
PlayerTGTRECYDSAVGTDLONG
Trayveon Williams44389.5026
Harold Fannin Jr.64348.5113
Quinshon Judkins65295.8016
Isaiah Bond00210.0021
Jerry Jeudy43124.007
Malachi Corley42115.5011
Cedric Tillman1188.008
Raheim Sanders1144.004
Brenden Bates1000.000

Defense

BUF Buffalo Bills defense
PlayerTKLSACKSTFLPDINTFFFR
Jordan Poyer110.511100
Matt Milano9010000
Cole Bishop7010000
Terrel Bernard6000000
Taron Johnson5000000
Andre Jones Jr.4000000
DaQuan Jones4001100
Dorian Williams4000000
Phidarian Mathis4000000
Tre'Davious White4001000
Greg Rousseau32.520000
AJ Epenesa3000000
Deone Walker3002000
Jordan Hancock3000000
T.J. Sanders3000000
Sam Franklin Jr.2000000
Shaq Thompson2000000
Christian Benford1000000
Joey Bosa1001000
CLE Cleveland Browns defense
PlayerTKLSACKSTFLPDINTFFFR
Carson Schwesinger14110000
Devin Bush9000000
Ronnie Hickman6000000
Grant Delpit4000000
Mohamoud Diabate4000000
Myles Harden4001000
Shelby Harris3000000
Alex Wright20.500000
D'Angelo Ross2000000
Donovan McMillon2000000
Jerome Baker2000000
Luke Wypler2000000
Mason Graham2000000
Tyson Campbell2000000
Myles Garrett10.500000
Harold Fannin Jr.1000000
Maurice Hurst II1000000
Rayshawn Jenkins1000000
Tre Avery1000000

Special Teams

Kicking

BUF Buffalo Bills kicking
PlayerFGPCTLONGXPPTS
Michael Badgley1/1100412/35
CLE Cleveland Browns kicking
PlayerFGPCTLONGXPPTS
Andre Szmyt2/2100412/28

Punting

BUF Buffalo Bills punting
PlayerNOYDSAVGTBIN 20LONG
Mitch Wishnowsky314949.71062
CLE Cleveland Browns punting
PlayerNOYDSAVGTBIN 20LONG
Corey Bojorquez210351.50152

Kick returns

BUF Buffalo Bills kick returns
PlayerNOYDSAVGLONGTD
Ray Davis49223.0260
CLE Cleveland Browns kick returns
PlayerNOYDSAVGLONGTD
Malachi Corley410726.8310

Punt returns

BUF Buffalo Bills punt returns
PlayerNOYDSAVGLONGTD
Mecole Hardman Jr.144.040
Khalil Shakir133.030
CLE Cleveland Browns punt returns
PlayerNOYDSAVGLONGTD
Gage Larvadain133.030

Bills vs Browns Fantasy Recap

The highlights, the fantasy box score, usage and opportunity, actual versus expected points, takeaways and next-week decisions.

Top Scorer

James Cook III

RB · BUF · RB6 weekly finish

26.4fantasy points

16 carries for 117 yards and 2 touchdowns; 1 catch for 17 yards on 2 targets. Handled 55% of the Bills' carries.

Biggest Overperformer

Harold Fannin Jr.

TE · CLE · TE2 weekly finish

19.5fantasy points

2 touchdowns on 1 carry and 6 targets lifted the day past the workload.

Biggest Underperformer

Josh Allen

QB · BUF · QB27 weekly finish

6.9fantasy points

Despite 19 pass attempts and 7 carries, Allen came up well short of what that workload is usually worth.

Fantasy Box Score

Fantasy points, weekly positional finish and game production for every offensive player
PlayerFPTSWeekly FinishGame Production
James Cook IIIRBBUF26.4RB616 CAR, 117 RUSH YDS, 1 REC, 17 REC YDS, 2 TD
Harold Fannin Jr.TECLE19.5TE21 CAR, 1 RUSH YDS, 4 REC, 34 REC YDS, 2 TD
Shedeur SandersQBCLE13.2QB22157 PASS YDS, 1 TD, 2 INT, 49 RUSH YDS
Quinshon JudkinsRBCLE10.1RB308 CAR, 22 RUSH YDS, 5 REC, 29 REC YDS
Trayveon WilliamsRBCLE9.5RB343 CAR, 17 RUSH YDS, 4 REC, 38 REC YDS
Ty JohnsonRBBUF7.6RB423 CAR, 16 YDS, 1 TD
Khalil ShakirWRBUF7.4WR544 REC, 34 YDS, 5 TGT
Josh AllenQBBUF6.9QB27130 PASS YDS, 17 RUSH YDS
Malachi CorleyWRCLE6.1WR643 CAR, 30 RUSH YDS, 2 REC, 11 REC YDS
Raheim SandersRBCLE5.6RB4811 CAR, 42 RUSH YDS, 1 REC, 4 REC YDS
Ray DavisRBBUF5.4RB503 CAR, 14 RUSH YDS, 2 REC, 20 REC YDS
Jackson HawesTEBUF4.6TE342 REC, 26 YDS, 2 TGT
Jerry JeudyWRCLE4.2WR813 REC, 12 YDS, 4 TGT
Tyrell ShaversWRBUF3.1WR891 REC, 21 YDS, 2 TGT
Dawson KnoxTEBUF2.0TE501 REC, 10 YDS, 2 TGT
Isaiah BondWRCLE2.0WR1001 CAR, -1 RUSH YDS, 0 REC, 21 REC YDS
Cedric TillmanWRCLE1.8WR1031 REC, 8 YDS, 1 TGT
Joshua PalmerWRBUF1.2WR1141 REC, 2 YDS, 1 TGT
Brandin CooksWRBUF0.0-0 REC, 0 YDS, 1 TGT
Brenden BatesTECLE0.0-0 REC, 0 YDS, 1 TGT
Dalton KincaidTEBUF0.0-0 REC, 0 YDS, 1 TGT

Usage & Opportunity

Buffalo Bills

Buffalo Bills snap, target and carry shares
PlayerSnap%Target%Carry%
Josh AllenQBBUF100%-24%
Joshua PalmerWRBUF70%6%-
Dawson KnoxTEBUF68%11%-
Jackson HawesTEBUF64%11%-
Tyrell ShaversWRBUF58%11%-
James Cook IIIRBBUF56%11%55%
Khalil ShakirWRBUF48%28%-
Dalton KincaidTEBUF38%6%-
Ty JohnsonRBBUF32%-10%
Brandin CooksWRBUF24%6%-
Ray DavisRBBUF16%11%10%

Cleveland Browns

Cleveland Browns snap, target and carry shares
PlayerSnap%Target%Carry%
Shedeur SandersQBCLE98%-13%
Harold Fannin Jr.TECLE86%22%3%
Jerry JeudyWRCLE73%15%-
Isaiah BondWRCLE48%-3%
Cedric TillmanWRCLE47%4%-
Malachi CorleyWRCLE45%15%10%
Brenden BatesTECLE42%4%-
Quinshon JudkinsRBCLE39%22%26%
Raheim SandersRBCLE30%4%35%
Trayveon WilliamsRBCLE30%15%10%

Shares of each team's own snaps, targets and carries in this game. A dash means none recorded or not available.

Actual vs Expected (XFP)

  1. James Cook IIIRBBUF26.413.7+12.7 above expected

    16 carries and 2 targets were worth 13.7 points at league-average rates; the touchdown and above-average yardage added the other 12.7.

    Opportunity: 16 carries and 2 targets

  2. Harold Fannin Jr.TECLE19.510.9+8.6 above expected

    Touchdowns supplied 12.0 of the 19.5 points, the part least likely to repeat.

    Opportunity: 1 carry and 6 targets

  3. Josh AllenQBBUF6.913.0−6.1 below expected

    19 pass attempts and 7 carries were worth 13.0 points at league-average rates.

    Opportunity: 19 pass attempts and 7 carries

  4. Ty JohnsonRBBUF7.61.9+5.7 above expected

    Touchdowns supplied 6.0 of the 7.6 points, the part least likely to repeat.

    Opportunity: 3 carries

  5. Quinshon JudkinsRBCLE10.115.4−5.3 below expected

    8 carries and 6 targets were worth 15.4 points at league-average rates.

    Opportunity: 8 carries and 6 targets

  6. Raheim SandersRBCLE5.68.8−3.2 below expected

    11 carries and 1 target were worth 8.8 points at league-average rates.

    Opportunity: 11 carries and 1 target

  7. Malachi CorleyWRCLE6.18.8−2.7 below expected

    3 carries and 4 targets were worth 8.8 points at league-average rates.

    Opportunity: 3 carries and 4 targets

  8. Jerry JeudyWRCLE4.26.8−2.6 below expected

    4 targets were worth 6.8 points at league-average rates.

    Opportunity: 4 targets

  9. Shedeur SandersQBCLE13.215.5−2.3 below expected

    29 pass attempts and 4 carries were worth 15.5 points at league-average rates. Turnovers cost 2.0 of it.

    Opportunity: 29 pass attempts and 4 carries

  10. Dawson KnoxTEBUF2.03.4−1.4 in line

    The points matched the role: 2 targets worth 3.4 expected.

    Opportunity: 2 targets

  11. Jackson HawesTEBUF4.63.4+1.2 in line

    The points matched the role: 2 targets worth 3.4 expected.

    Opportunity: 2 targets

  12. Khalil ShakirWRBUF7.48.5−1.1 in line

    The points matched the role: 5 targets worth 8.5 expected.

    Opportunity: 5 targets

  13. Trayveon WilliamsRBCLE9.58.8+0.7 in line

    The points matched the role: 3 carries and 4 targets worth 8.8 expected.

    Opportunity: 3 carries and 4 targets

  14. Tyrell ShaversWRBUF3.13.4−0.3 in line

    The points matched the role: 2 targets worth 3.4 expected.

    Opportunity: 2 targets

  15. Ray DavisRBBUF5.45.3+0.1 in line

    The points matched the role: 3 carries and 2 targets worth 5.3 expected.

    Opportunity: 3 carries and 2 targets

xFP is what a player's opportunities were worth at league-average rates. A gap measures scoring above or below that workload, not necessarily the quality of the performance.

Fantasy Takeaways & Stock Changes

Jackson Hawes Stock Up

TE · BUF

Played 64% of the snaps, up from a 45% season average. The role change matters more for future fantasy value than this game's 4.6 points. If the role holds, Hawes is a start for the rest of the season.

Quinshon Judkins Stock Down

RB · CLE

8 carries against a 17.1 average before this game. Played 39% of the snaps, down from a 51% average before this game. Bench Judkins for the rest of the season until the role comes back.

Harold Fannin Jr. Sell High

TE · CLE

Touchdowns were 62% of the day; without them it was a 7.5-point game. Sell-high window: don't count on the same touchdowns for the rest of the season.

Ty Johnson Sell High

RB · BUF

Scored on a 3-touch role: a touchdown-or-bust profile. Sell-high window: don't count on the same touchdowns for the rest of the season.

Bills vs Browns Game Flow

How the game unfolded, possession by possession, and how each offense called it.

How the Game Swung

Cleveland opened at 22% win probability and fell below 2% in the third quarter.

Browns win probability

Browns win probability by game minuteBrowns started at 22%, stood at 6% at halftime and finished at 0%, across 8 scoring plays.

Key Swings

  1. +19Sanders → Fannin, 13-yd TD23% → 42%Q1 10:42
  2. −20Cook 44-yd TD run43% → 23%Q1 7:47
  3. −14Johnson 2-yd TD run26% → 12%Q2 12:54
  4. −13Cook 3-yd TD run19% → 6%Q2 2:23
  5. +12Szmyt 41-yd FG7% → 19%Q4 8:46

Swing in Browns win probability, in points

Play calling, Bills vs Browns
Buffalo BillsMeasureCleveland Browns
50Plays64
42%Pass rate52%
4.5Yds / dropback4.1
5.7Yds / carry5.2
2/8Third downs8/14

Efficiency edge Buffalo ran 14 fewer plays but gained 0.5 more yards per carry.

  • Top targets
  • BUF Shakir 28% · Knox 11% · Hawes 11%
  • CLE Fannin 22% · Judkins 22% · Jeudy 15%

Possession Results

How each possession ended, Bills vs Browns
ResultBUFCLE
Touchdowns32
Field goals12
Punts32
Turnovers02
Turnovers on downs21

BUF turnover edge: +2

  • The Browns opened the scoring on their first possession, a 8-play, 69-yard drive that ended in a touchdown.
  • The Bills scored touchdowns on three of their first three drives.
All 20 possessions, drive by drive
Drive chart
TeamStartPlaysYardsTimeResult
CLEQ1 15:008694:18Touchdown
BUFQ1 10:425802:55Touchdown
CLEQ1 7:476324:52Interception
BUFQ1 2:559615:01Touchdown
CLEQ2 12:5413657:16Field goal
BUFQ2 5:387683:15Touchdown
CLEQ2 2:233-20:47Punt
BUFQ2 1:363-121:30Punt
CLEQ2 0:06200:06End of half
BUFQ3 15:00382:14Punt
CLEQ3 12:464122:07Interception
BUFQ3 10:39421:02Field goal
CLEQ3 9:3714678:01Touchdown
BUFQ3 1:367363:06Downs
CLEQ4 13:308434:44Field goal
BUFQ4 8:463-121:41Punt
CLEQ4 7:054-52:03Downs
BUFQ4 5:025192:15Downs
CLEQ4 2:474-111:09Punt
BUFQ4 1:38591:38End of game
About these numbers

Possessions that ended with the clock running out at the half or the end of the game aren't counted.

Personnel groupings, average depth of target and pass rate over expected appear when the tracking feed is connected.

Bills vs Browns Rivalry

The all-time series, recent meetings and both teams' seasons to date.

Bills vs Browns Head-to-Head

All-time series
13–11Browns lead, 24 meetings since 1972
Postseason
1–0Browns won in 1989
Largest Bills win
42–01990
Largest Browns win
41–201978

2–0 Bills lead2 meetings since 2021, incl. playoffs

Season to Date Entering Week 16 (Through Week 15)

Season to date, Bills vs Browns
BillsStatBrowns
10-4Record3-11
29.4Points per game16.1
381.2Yards per game264.4
6.0Yards per play4.3
23.1Points allowed per game23.7
312.6Yards allowed per game279.1

Bills vs Browns Betting Recap

How the game finished against the spread, total and moneyline, the line movement and each team's betting trends.

Game Results vs Closing Odds

Spread

CLE +10.5

Covered by 7.5

Game total

43 pts

Over 41.5 by 1.5

  • Buffalo Bills2326−3
  • Cleveland Browns2015.5+4.5

The Browns beat their implied total and the Bills fell short of theirs; the Fantasy tab has the player lines.

2025 season through Week 16, this game included. Nothing after it counts.

Recent results, oldest to newest (this game last)

Each team's last 4 results against the closing lines through Week 16
TeamWeekOppFinalLineATSTotalO/U
BUFWk 13@ PITW 26–7−3W44.5U
Wk 14vs CINW 39–34−6L54.5O
Wk 15@ NEW 35–31−2.5W49.5O
Wk 16@ CLEW 23–20−10.5L41.5O
CLEWk 13vs SFL 8–26+5.5L35.5U
Wk 14vs TENL 29–31−4.5L33.5O
Wk 15@ CHIL 3–31+7.5L38.5U
Wk 16vs BUFL 20–23+10.5W41.5O

Results and trends are graded against each game's closing line, overtime included. Pushes are counted separately.

21+. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. Betting availability depends on your state.

Bills and Browns in Fantasy

The two teams don't meet again this season. If you roster a Bill or a Brown, these answer the week-to-week question.

Bills vs Browns Game FAQ

Who won the 2025 Bills vs Browns Week 16 game?

The Buffalo Bills beat the Cleveland Browns 23–20 in Week 16 of the 2025 season. The game was played at FirstEnergy Stadium in Cleveland on December 21, 2025. See the Bills' 2025 schedule.

What was the final score of Bills vs Browns?

The final score was Bills 23, Browns 20. The Bills led 20–10 at halftime, and the second half went Bills 3, Browns 10.

What happened in the Bills vs Browns game?

Buffalo led 20–10 at halftime and won 23–20, though Cleveland took the second half 10–3. Cleveland outgained the Bills 294–259, but the Bills averaged 5.2 yards per play. James Cook III led all players with a catch for 17 yards, plus 16 carries for 117 rushing yards and 2 touchdowns. The Browns committed 2 turnovers, the Bills none.

Who scored the most fantasy points in Bills vs Browns?

James Cook III led the game with 26.4 PPR fantasy points, the RB6 of Week 16, on a catch for 17 yards, plus 16 carries for 117 rushing yards and 2 touchdowns. Harold Fannin Jr. was next with 19.5 (TE2). See James Cook III's 2025 game log.

Who led Bills vs Browns in passing, rushing and receiving?

Shedeur Sanders (CLE) led all passers with 20 of 29 for 157 yards, a touchdown and 2 interceptions. James Cook III (BUF) led in rushing with 16 carries for 117 yards and 2 touchdowns. Trayveon Williams (CLE) led in receiving with 4 catches for 38 yards.

How many fantasy points did James Cook III score against the Browns?

James Cook III scored 26.4 points in PPR leagues, 25.9 in half-PPR and 25.4 in standard scoring against the Browns in Week 16 of the 2025 season, on a catch for 17 yards, plus 16 carries for 117 rushing yards and 2 touchdowns. He handled 55% of his team's carries.

Who outperformed and underperformed expected fantasy points in Bills vs Browns?

James Cook III outperformed his expected fantasy points the most, scoring 26.4 PPR points on 13.7 xFP (+12.7). Josh Allen fell furthest short, with 6.9 points on 13.0 xFP (−6.1). A gap either way reflects efficiency and touchdowns in one game; it is not a forecast. For matchups ahead, see fantasy points allowed by position.

How did the Bills beat the Browns?

The Bills beat the Browns 23–20 because they averaged 5.2 yards per play to 4.6 and won the turnover battle 2–0.

Which team won the turnover battle in Bills vs Browns?

The Bills won the turnover battle 2–0: the Browns gave the ball away 2 times and the Bills not at all. The Bills won the game.

What is the all-time Bills vs Browns record?

The Browns lead the all-time series 13–11 across 24 meetings since 1972, including a 1–0 record in the postseason.

When did the Bills and Browns last play before this game?

Before Week 16 of 2025, they last met in the 2022 season on November 20, 2022, when the Bills beat the Browns 31–23.

Have the Bills and Browns met in the playoffs?

Yes, 1 time, most recently in the 1989 playoffs. The Bills are 0–1 against the Browns in the postseason.

What was the closing spread for Bills vs Browns?

The consensus closing spread at kickoff was Bills −10.5, making the Buffalo Bills 10.5-point favorites, with a closing total of 41.5. That implied about 26.0 points for the Bills and 15.5 for the Browns.

Did Bills vs Browns go over or under the total?

The game went over. The consensus closing total was 41.5, and the teams combined for 43 points, 1.5 over the number.

Who covered the spread in Bills vs Browns?

The Browns covered as 10.5-point underdogs against the closing line of Bills −10.5. The final margin was 3 points.

Set your lineup for this game